-
“We have a lion problem in Spring Canyon,” my neighbor Keri says to anyone who will listen -- neighbors, strangers, wildlife officers. We do not have a lion problem. We are blessed with the presence of mountain lions in the canyon behind our houses. It’s a fairly deep canyon, 200 feet, and two miles long. There are plenty of deer in the canyon, the forest, the farmland around the canyon, for the lions to eat. I’ve hoped to see a mountain lion each day of the fifteen years I’ve lived here, but, though I’ve seen a few tracks and some scat, an occasional kill along the driveway or in the woods, the blessing of seeing an actual lion has been denied me. Until recently.

zoom photo of 'my' lion
The problem with telling people you’ve seen a lion is that the news spreads; before you know it the state bounty hunters will come running with their dogs to tree the lion, and their guns to take it out. I saw two lions last month, but I haven’t told many people. Meanwhile, holding my joy close, I’ve heard four accounts of different sightings since then. A neighbor to the south, Pete, drove a young lion out of the field when he was cutting hay. I heard about this one first from the ditch rider, Tom, who also told me the same neighbor accidently mowed over two spotted fawns while cutting Tom’s hay.
It was awful. Tom had seen the doe get up from the field when Pete started cutting at the top, and he’d walked down to see if there was a fawn, but he missed them. The first few days they’re hardwired to stay put no matter what the threat. The mower decapitated one and mangled the other. “The only bad thing about haying season,” Tom said. He found them later in the day when he saw the doe sitting back out there, grieving. He moved them down to the edge of the canyon, knowing something would come take them. The next day one was gone, the other a few days later.
I heard about the same lion sighting from Dave at the Post Office, who lives up here too. “It was a big one,” he said, his eyes wide. “Our neighbor called to let us know, so the kids don’t go playing in the woods alone.” “That’s a good idea anyway,” I said, “you never know when they might be around.” Then I added something about how it really makes you feel alive to live where there are lions, but he got a dark look on his face and moved on to the next customer.
Tom told me a couple of weeks later that a woman across the canyon had called a rancher down the road in a panic because a lion had killed a doe in her field and “What should I do?” The rancher told her to stay away and let the lion finish eating its kill. That was a relief, not something you expect to hear from a person who routinely complains that any deer a lion takes is one less for the hunters.
A few nights ago at a dinner party the hostess told us she’d seen two lions on her road in the past week. Her response was mixed between awe, delight, and fear that they’d get into her husband’s herd and take a cow. By any standard since I’ve lived here that is a lot of lion sightings in one month. Then I heard just this morning that Albert, who lives up canyon, saw a lion a couple of weeks ago. Albert was sitting on his patio in the morning drinking coffee, with his dog lying beside him. All of a sudden the dog was on point, and a lion came up over the rim and stood looking at them. Albert stood up, the lion lingered, then turned and sauntered off. Casual and calm as could be.
During this month, I had been watching a nest of redtail hawks fledging in the canyon. I’d tried shooting a few videos but they were always on the other side of the canyon, always a little too far away for the camera not to shake on full zoom. That morning my cousin Melinda, visiting from Kentucky, suggested “Don’t you have a tripod?” I do have a tripod. I was just too lazy to dust it off and carry it down to the canyon. So she carried it.
At the rim, I spotted one of the young hawks, set up the camera on the tripod, and lost the bird when it flew across and into some brush. I was searching with my binoculars for a long while, then lowered them and rested my eyes by scanning back to the north along the canyon. There on a big rock ledge I saw two figures walking side by side, one just slightly ahead of the other. “Dogs? Coyotes? Lions!” went my mind, and I whispered “There’s two lions,” to Melinda just as they disappeared into the oaks. She got up from the bench where she sat with her binoculars and strode to the edge -- “sssshhhh! Don’t move!” I hissed. She froze. I turned on the camera though I could no longer see the lions, and stood to join her a few feet away. Somehow the lions crossed an open expanse without our seeing them, but the dog uttered a low guttural noise unlike anything I’d ever heard from him. “Sssshh,” I whispered to him, “it’s okay.”
Then another noise, a mewing cawing yowlish chirping noise, and we saw the second lion, rounding the far edge of a bunch of oaks, heading downhill, talking. I moved back to the camera. They saw us. They were both under the oaks near the edge of the creek, looking up at us. The talking lion stood frozen, looking up; the other lion already lay behind, in dappled shade, looking up. I found them in the camera. Here, after fifteen years of longing, were not one, but two lions, and I had a camera, and I had a tripod. The standing lion stood for awhile then lay down, never taking its eyes from us. Everyone who has seen the video agrees, this front lion is a young lion. The back lion’s age and gender remain in dispute. Some “experts” believe it is a sibling to the first, some argue based on possible differences in appearance that it is the mother. The truth is, it’s hard to tell. Being there, in the moment, I’d say they were identical. In the video, the rear lion looks a little heavier, a little darker, and could be an adult. At the time, I told Melinda they were last year’s cubs, striking out on their own.
Melinda, the dog, and I watched (and filmed) the two lions for about twelve minutes. Then, it seemed, we had mutually evaluated each other and concluded there was no threat. Honestly, I was hungry. I suggested to Melinda that we move along and get breakfast. At that same moment the young lion turned its head, then shifted its weight, got up, turned, and walked away through the oaks, as if in agreement.
I wasn’t only hungry. Melinda had said, about halfway into this experience, “My question is, where’s mama?” I replied with unwarranted confidence, “Oh, she’s over there somewhere. She’s not over here stalking us, I’m sure of that.” For the next six minutes or so, I mulled that over. I wasn’t sure of anything. Perhaps she was over here stalking us. The uncanny calm of the two lions below got me wondering, where is mama?
“And later,” Melinda added a minute or so after asking about mama, “we need to talk about mountain lion etiquette.” “Yes,” I replied. And we did, later. I told her, “Whatever you do, don’t run. Make yourself big, pull your shirt up around your shoulders, make noise, shoo it away. DO NOT TURN YOUR BACK. Do not run. Call the dogs.” Mountain lions tend to attack from behind, with wild speed and silence. Their teeth and jaws are perfectly adapted to separate the vertebrae of their prey, severing the spinal cord swiftly.
It’s one thing to know, theoretically, that you live where there are lions. I have known this since I moved onto this rugged land. It is quite another thing to have seen them, calmly watching you from 150 feet away. “Too calm,” said one friend when she saw the video. After hearing of all the other lion sightings in the area this summer I know what she means. Those lions we saw were too calm. All these lions are misbehaving. If they do not develop a reasonable fear of humans, they are done for.
Can you believe there are actually still bounty hunters in the American West? Is this an archaic concept or what? Humans have encroached so mercilessly on the habitat of our planet’s top predators it’s a wonder you don’t read about it every day: “jogger attacked by mountain lion,” “hiker mauled by grizzly,” “man loses arm to alligator,” “toddler bitten by fox,” or wolf, or tiger, or shark. Come to think of it, you do hear about a fair number of such unfortunate encounters, unfortunate for both participants, as whatever the outcome for the human, the wild animal usually gets killed one way or another. Whence derives the mentality that presumes humans matter more than other species? What entitles us to build and pave, build and pave, over acres, miles, of territory that’s been wild for untold generations of other species?
It’s bad enough that we encroach, destroy, gobble up. Then we send the big guns, the bounty hunters, after the new keystone species, when they cross the line. (The old keystone species had other criteria, primarily of sensitivity to our handiworks.) Now our science has finally figured it out: if you protect the large predators in an ecosystem, to the point that they (appear to) have genetic viability as a species, i.e., they won’t interbreed or otherwise drive themselves to extinction, you also de facto protect all species upon which they depend, plant and animal.
If these lions that are gracing our neighborhood this summer do get out of hand, if they actually attack a human, I might concede that “we have a lion problem.” I can see both sides. Would I sacrifice myself or my dog to a lion if it would ensure survival of their species? Absolutely. Would I sacrifice my child, if I had one? Doubtful. We know there is not just one lion at large, for I saw two at once. There could be three, or four, even more. It feels as though they’re all around. As I said, it’s one thing to know, theoretically, and it’s another to have seen them, to feel them in a visceral way, to know you are potential prey.
The next morning Melinda and I walked the dogs as usual, and the next. She was leaving in a few more days. She said, when we talked about the lions the next day, that because we’d been out looking for birds, because we’d been looking at and for and talking about birds since she’d arrived a week before, when I said “there are two lions” she thought I must be using some shorthand for “lion hawk,” or “lion sparrow,” or “lion wren.” (I especially like the last one, lion wren. The idea delights me.) So she stood up and walked to the rim with her binoculars expecting some new bird. While the significance of the encounter enveloped me in the first second, it took minutes and then hours to really dawn on her.
I could not shut up about it. “Lions…” I’d breathe every so often for the next few days, “mountain lions… two of them…,” and so on. I was high as a kite, high as a soaring redtail, high as a lion wren. Still am, weeks later. Whatever the outcome, this was the gift of a lifetime for me: not one, but two, and the camera, and the tripod. And we were all so calm, so present, so connected in the moment. While my cousin was beginning to wonder “where’s mama?” i.e., what is the threat to me?, I was still simply breathless at their beauty, and utterly focused on them, on watching them, and keeping them in the camera.
The third morning after, Melinda slept late. I had to face the canyon, walk the dogs, alone. I could have waited for her, but I wanted to get back on the horse. In a few days she’d be gone. If I didn’t go back to my usual routine, my fifteen year long routine, going out alone every morning with the dogs, I thought I might get yard-bound, stay in the fence, think too much about those powerful paws. Though I doubt I’ll see them again. Why should today be different from any other day of the past fifteen years, when I have known, theoretically, lions live here, and I have not seen hide nor hair of one.
When I saw those lions last month I had not heard of any of these other sightings. Now I am sore afraid for the lions. Is our young lion in Spring Canyon the same one that Pete spooked out of the hayfield a couple of miles south? The same one that panicked the rancher’s wife, that greeted Albert over coffee? Are these the same two lions Sam and Betty saw ten miles away? Certainly they could be; lions can have a home range of more than 30 square miles. Or, they could be seven different lions, all moving through, all miles away by now. But my question is, why are we seeing so many lions this summer?
Human trespass was rare in this canyon until all those new houses were built three years ago. Lion sightings were rare until this summer. Did our reverent observation that morning, our communion with the two lions, deceive them about human nature? Were they already that bold, or did our calm encourage them to be unwary? Or is this a case of self-fulfilling prophecy? Has Keri, walking, stalking up and down the canyon now for three years with her pack of dogs, slashing and burning native cover, cutting trail wherever she pleases without regard to people’s boundaries, or lions’, acclimated them to humans and dogs, so that now we do have a lion problem? Or is it simply that it is a good year for deer, and therefore a good year for lions?
I did not tell the dinner party about our two lions, or Dave at the Post Office, or Keri. Since our sighting I have shown the video to a handful of people, all sworn to secrecy. “Lives are at stake,” I said. Despite my utmost precautions, however, these lions might do themselves in through being too bold, too fearless, too calm. It’s out of my hands. All I can do is watch and wait, keep my secret from my neighbors, and count my blessings.
ADDENDUM
A Month Later
All this previous philosophy is dependent on one thing: the assumption that the lions are sane. A new report comes today of three more sightings in the past two weeks, in one of which the lion appeared to be mad. Some ranchers to the east saw two lions at once about three weeks ago; a man across the canyon had one of his lion hound pack pulled out of a collar off a chain and eaten; and a couple a mile south of here sleeping on their porch were awakened by their dogs when a lion began hurling itself at their fence. They watched for 35 minutes as the lion continued to pace and lunge, and the way I heard it, the lion was foaming at the mouth and dripping six inch strings of drool. Of course, the “rabid” lion might simply have been poisoned, too. Anyway, way too many lion sightings for comfort for a six week period. They’re going to get themselves in trouble.
I still walk the woods, go irrigating, and work in the garden. The only differeince is that in my garden basket with my notebook, cameras, glasses and sunscreen, I’ve now added my gun. Just in case.
-
She had asked that in lieu of sending flowers, anyone who wanted to remember her please to plant a tree. I planted two. And one backup, so that’s three. She was worth at least three trees to me. The peach, purchased just this spring, saved from the parking lot of City Market, the only peach there, barely rooted, clinging to sodden clay in the heat of the concrete lot, the peach is doing well where I planted it, over the grave of the old dog and Michael’s second cat.
This lime, though, bought the winter after she died, mail order from a reputable company, I have just attempted to de-scale. I knew she was in trouble this spring, and took preliminary measures just before summer, rinsing and rubbing leaves and stems, drowning the soil, isolating. But I just couldn’t find time to get around to repotting and giving a thorough cleaning until today, mid-July. I’ve never seen such scale. Without reading glasses I’d been passing her by, watering, noting with interest the columns of ants going up and down, cultivating the scale. I saw there was an awful lot of scale, but I kept putting off dealing with it. Knowing that when I finally turned my attention to the problem it would be an hour’s intensive pruning, soaping, rinsing, brushing, rubbing, soaking, rinsing roots clean, repotting effort, and deciding, in the midst of all else every day demanded that I do, to wait, day after day, just one more day. That messy endeavor now accomplished, she stands stripped of all leaves in a wide, accommodating pot, fresh soil washed in around clean roots. Those blasted ants, growing that scale out of all proportion to anything I’ve seen before. I must look into that. I know some ants grow aphids for their honeydew. I wonder how exactly these ants benefit from cultivating scale.
So here I am cleaning this little lime tree, finally tending to it after months of avoidance, and I think of Darlene, and how I avoided her decline, too, into the infestation of cancer that took her down. How I could have insisted that she get her spine checked even before she could move to Denver, except that on her schedule she sold the house first, then moved to Denver, then dealt with what fresh hell the cancer had to give her. Unfortunately for both of us, the cancer had its own agenda, squeezing her spine with pain she chalked up to having fallen in that first seizure at the store, hitting her back on the counter. I bought that. It was feasible, and she wasn’t willing to hear it might be more cancer.
I stepped back from her when she snapped at me for interfering. We hadn’t yet grown close enough for me to put my foot down, though you’d have thought after 25 years I could have. I drove down for Christmas specifically to have a talk with her about “what if you die from this?” But we never got around to it. Like the scale. It grew and grew, the cancer squeezing her spine, the likelihood she’d die of it, while we drove out and got the dogs groomed, dined at restaurants, bought Bach flower remedies, met her friends for Ladies’ Night, shopped for movies. She made sure we made it downtown to Larry’s Hats so I could find what I was looking for, which turned out to be a red felt soft-brimmed hat with a dash of red feathers sweeping forward on one side. People never fail to comment when I wear it. “Where’d you get it?” I tell them I got it at Larry’s Hats, and leave it at that, because always I am transported back to that morning, passing the store first, then coming back hunting, finding a parking spot with a meter on the sidestreet, crossing with the light, she and I in the city, the narrow doorway, the shelves and racks of hats, all decorated, if not made, the clerk informed us, by Larry.
Darlene was sicker then than she let on. Tight in on herself yet still reaching out. We spent a lot of time that visit focusing on food, what she could eat that radiation didn’t make her sick of. Each afternoon we drove up the interstate for her radiation treatments. That didn’t leave a lot of time or energy for anything else. We watched a lot of TV, a marathon of The Dog Whisperer, which she loved and I’d never seen. It snowed the day before I was supposed to leave, and I ended up spending New Year’s Eve. It was a subdued celebration. By then we were both in denial. It seemed like there was plenty of time, according to her schedule: first she’d get the house sold, then move to Denver and get in with the Cancer Center there, and see some really good doctors. She thought she had plenty of time. She had to think she had time. She couldn’t face not having time, having stayed in Albuquerque, unhappy, for so long. And I remembered all the times I’d heard the workers in the field, nurses, counselors, tell me “Each person has to face illness and death in their own way. You can’t try to make it your way.”
I guess I realized that she was going to die no matter what. So why not let her get through it with denial? I jumped on board. It would not have been my way, I think, if I’d been in her shoes. But I too thought she had more time. That we would have more time. That maybe she wouldn’t die, so why be grim? She was working so hard on positive thinking, Lance Armstrong’s book at her bedside. If I’d had $3000 I’d have taken her to that place in California where Gretchen got so inspired. But I did have the money, I lacked the commitment -- and she would never have accepted it from me anyway. We held each other ridiculously at arms’ length for the last of her life, from the time the second cancer came. She chose a course right then of solitary struggle.
The last couple of months, after she’d sold the house and moved, either she chose not to answer my calls or her sister deflected them, and I let them. I walked on by that lime tree looking with interest at the columns of ants, I called and left messages and waited for her to be ready to reply. Deep in my own denial. First she was at home, then in the hospital, then Hospice. Even knowing the average Hospice patient stays only 21 days between admission and dying, I kept walking by, as though by my denying she would last longer. Finally, despite her sister’s insistence I not come visit, I called the Hospice and talked with a nurse, who said she’d ask Darlene if I could come. She called me back a few hours later. “I asked if she’d like to see her friend Rita, and she blinked her eyes. It’s the only way she can communicate,” she said, “...if you want to see her you’d better come now.”
I was off in a matter of hours, after making arrangements for the young dogs to get taken to the kennel, and taking the old dying dog with me, I blasted across the March night interstate, over the dark icy mountains, into the big clanging city. I parked, trembling from the drive. I entered the quiet Hospice building, and they led me to her bed. She turned her head toward me. I stood beside her, said “I’m sorry I didn’t come sooner. Your sister told me not to come --” She turned away. I wish I’d kissed her then. Full on the lips. Kissed her goodbye, kissed her one last time for all the promise there had been between us. She was so frail. Her right hand lay at her neck. “I want to touch you,” I said. “May I touch you?” She flung her hand away to the side, looked back at me for one searing second, one tear, then turned her eyes from mine.
That last look floored me. I have never seen such darkness in someone’s eyes. All the rage, all the sorrow -- was it aimed at me? Had I so let her down? Or, bitterness and profound loss, was it simply the agony of dying young?
Later, deep in the night, I talked to her. Told her she’d been robbed, told her we had both been robbed, of our friendship, our future. Told her she was the only girl I’d ever loved; that of all the people I knew she was the most fun to do things with, projects, household repairs, shopping, whatever. Remembered when we met, when we sat by the sinkhole for three days watching that alligator hold onto a heron. We were so sure the heron would die, any minute, give up, give in, go under. But it would not. The alligator tried to shift his grip every now and then, and we kept thinking, this is it; but it was not. And finally, one last time that alligator let go for a split second to shift again and the heron flapped free. After three days. It was a small alligator, it’s true, and a small heron, but a mighty struggle nonetheless. That heron hung around for weeks as its leg festered and swelled, and just about the time Darlene and I were ready to give up, call for help and try to catch the bird, it started getting better. Before long it was gone.
I called up those early days in the swamp when I’d sometimes sleep over in their kingsize bed between her and Tina, like a child between parents, a straight girl between lovers, and in the morning we’d have homemade eggamuffins. How she and I vied for best kisser with our neighbor Rob as judge, one night in the balcony at the Bancroft Theater where he was playing keyboard in the band. Tina was away that summer, and I slept over, and we continued in bed trying to prove who was the better kisser, a straight girl or a lover of women, and we called it a tie. How ever since then and after all my too many men, she was the only girl for me. As soon as I started to speak her breathing slowed, grew deeper. As I told her all the things I needed her to know from our life together, lived and unlived, her long easy breaths accompanied me. “I’m here now until the end,” I said. “The only thing left I can do is witness. You will not die alone.”
I stopped speaking. After a few more inhalations the cadence of her breathing changed again, back to the ragged intermittent sips she’d been breathing before I spoke. A few hours later I moved to the recliner at the foot of her bed. Every now and then I’d tell her “I’m still here. I love you.” Between nurses’ visits to check on her complexion, add morphine, shift her head, I drifted into sleep. I dreamed we were speaking together. I was telling her all the things I had just told her awake, and she responded. She told me things I needed to hear, too. We talked easily of love, and the end. I awoke startled when the nurse came back in, but I woke with a smile, and I felt that dream was a gift, a communication from Darlene, what her spirit was saying to mine.
Later that day family came in and out. The morning nurse said “I don’t think she’ll make it to night.” She died at five p.m., took her last breath surrounded by two sisters, a brother-in-law, and a niece. And me. I’d left about four when they had all arrived, and lay down in the room next door to nap. I heard them murmur, then laugh, murmur then laugh. She would have wanted that. I felt out of place. They called me in for her last few minutes. Her sister said “Is she gone?” just like my brother had asked about our mother. Her niece said “Yes,” just as I had. Her sister burst into tears, just as my brother had. A scene rerun at every bedside death no doubt, with varying players. Then the first of the tears came to me, suddenly jumping out, collapsing.
She’s still gone. More than a year later, I still think of her every day, and of what might have been had she lived. Sometimes I cry again. I water the trees I planted in her name, the two little limes in pots that I walked by all winter, spring, summer, denying; and the peach just taking root in the ground. The limes, neglected, did not die but grew feeble. If I had intervened in March, or February, they’d have been free of scale by now and thriving. If I had reached past her denial, not given up like that heron, believed in death enough to take action, proclaim my love in the moment, not waited, could I have persuaded her to move faster, more radically against the cancer? How many lessons will it take for me to pay attention, to be wholly present in the face of death?
-
The other day I saw a boy rolling across a parking lot on
those sneakers with wheels in the heels. He was loving it, taking a few steps
to get momentum then gliding forward with his right leg in front, a few more
steps, a glide leading with his right. I watched him cross in front of me and
smiled at his pride and delight. But I wanted to catch him and say “You need to
switch your lead from time to time. You need to use your body the opposite way
and not only the way that comes naturally.” I have long lamented the fact that
nobody ever taught me how to walk, that nobody teaches children the mechanics
and symmetry of their bodies, that children who do not do sports in school can
end up virtually crippled by middle-age, simply from lack of balance and
symmetry in the way they use their bodies.
I spent most hours of my childhood years curled in a chair
with a good book. I always sat the same way, with my knees bent and legs pulled
up to my left side, torso twisted the same direction to see the book that
rested on the knees. Nobody ever said, “Hey, that’s going to make you
cockamamie, sit the other way now and then.” Or better yet, “get up off your
bottom and run somewhere.” In the past 15 years, with the assistance of various
teachers including yoga and Brother Psalm, I’ve become gradually aware of how
crooked I am. Brother Psalm used to walk around the town where I lived with his
hands pressed together in Namasté, bowing to people he met or embracing them on
both sides. He preached the benefits of “right-side-left-side” casually when
someone offered to shake hands, and from the pulpit with his poetry at open
stage. For Brother Psalm, the right-handed left-brained dominance of the
military-industrial complex, which he called Babylon,
could be mitigated by everyone using both sides equally.
Like any spiritual path the road to health and healing
requires both discipline and acceptance. I’m not good at either, but I did hear
the wisdom in Brother Psalm’s words and actions, and began to explore using my
left side equally with my right. Ever notice how almost everyone reaches into a
hug toward the right, putting left shoulders and cheeks together? We are a
right-handed culture. We drive on the right and hug on the right. I started
small, trying to hug to the left, brush my teeth and write with my left hand. I
became proficient in the latter but only if I wrote cursive backwards, so that
it could be read through the back of the page or in a mirror. It took many more
years of noticing the subtlety of my right-sided dominance before I became
aware that it was nearly impossible for me to sit with my knees bent toward my right
side.
I’ve suffered chronic pain for years. I’ve tried
purification diets, Tai Chi, and yoga off and on for years. Tai Chi helped,
there’s no doubt about that, but when my teacher moved away I lacked the
discipline to find another. Yoga means unity, we are taught, and perhaps it has
been my lack of discipline in not doing a daily asana practice that has caused
me to still have daily pain. Yet yoga remains a steady source of comfort and
has kept me from feeling worse than I do, while the diets, which always feel
terrific, never last. I am a carb junkie and I love a martini in the evening. I
also enjoy cannabis more than I ought, and have suspected for years that it
might be contributing to pain in my joints (no pun intended). Chinese and
Ayurvedic traditions would likely concur with this hypothesis. Most major
joints on my right side and some on the left have swelled, ached or been
incapacitated at some time over the past 35 years, and my right hip has been
giving me fits for the past three. Intuition suggests that the source of this
problem originated, or the first symptom appeared, in my right ankle when I was
14 years old and trying out for the track team.
A sharp persistent pain accompanied by stiffness was
diagnosed as osteochondritis dessicans
by a Greek doctor who prescribed a cast to the knee for one month, followed by
a permanent excuse from all P.E. classes through the rest of high school and
college. A small triangular tip of bone in my ankle was dead, he said, and
showed the gray spot on an x-ray. It did not get blood supply. Why, I wanted to
know. It just happens sometimes, was his answer. He said, “If you overdo with
this ankle the bone will break and you will have to have surgery to have it
removed, and your ankle will be weak forever.” For seven years I favored that
ankle. I quit running and jumping and I danced only cautiously. I didn’t roller
skate or ice skate with the other kids. I was gleefully relieved at no longer
having to participate in field hockey. Of course, the irony of his prescription
was that it made my ankle weak forever anyway, and my whole right side even
more out of kilter. But I did not begin to understand this until recently.
Ten years ago at the age of 38 both my knees blew up to the
size of a football two days apart. The first knee I took to my friend the
doctor, who drove me to the ER and drew off 80 cc’s of fluid, then x-rayed it
and told me I had the knees of an 80-year-old. The next day the right knee blew
up. I iced it and stayed off it for a week, then spent the next six months
learning to walk again. For awhile I went up and down stairs on my ass. Later I
carried lawn chairs out into the woods so that when I walked the dogs I could
stop and sit every few hundred feet. A few sessions of PT taught me that I’d
been hyper extending my knees during an assiduous program of forward bends, but
at $6 a minute I quickly let go of the PT and turned back to yoga to strengthen
my quads. It worked. It helped, anyway, and my knees became functional again.
Since then I’ve been told by various therapists, yoga
teachers and doctors that: my lumbar curve is backwards, I have a touch of scoliosis,
there’s a little arthritis in my hips, my thoracic curve is backwards, my right
leg is a little longer than my left (and
that it isn’t), my left hip is canted back, and several other malfunctions I’ve
forgotten. A massage healer and friend I used to see sometimes pointed out that
the tissue of my right thigh felt distinctly more dense than that of my left
(which I had noticed), and (which I had not noticed) that I did not swing my
left arm when I walked and that I stood always on the same leg when doing
dishes. I began to consciously swing my left arm and to stand on each leg alternately
or on both while at the kitchen sink. Now I can’t remember, was it the left leg
or the right leg that held the weight for all those years with the opposite hip
cocked out?
Still, despite a conscious effort to practice
right-side-left-side for more than a decade, I am plagued with the pain of
asymmetry. I offer these tiresome details only in the hope that they may mirror
someone else’s and thereby be of help. I’ve been on a discouraging odyssey of
doctor visits and medical tests for the past year, after yoga and valium failed
to solve this persistent hip pain. Every doctor wants a patient’s problem to be
his or her own thing – until it isn’t. They’ve all said “I think it’s X, let’s
try Z.” Nobody suggested “It could be this, or this, or this, or this… let’s
explore all the possibilities.” I saw Dr. J in the local clinic in the summer
of 2005, and she said “Take it easy for a few weeks.” She gave me Vicodin for
the pain and Valium to make it possible for me to back off the gardening I was
so intent upon accomplishing. It got better. I went back to gardening. It felt
like joint pain, so I pursued it with my yoga teacher, whose instruction helped
alleviate the discomfort. I thought I was on the right track, but it came back.
It diminished and increased, seemingly according to which yoga postures I
emphasized.
A year ago I went to see Dr. D, an osteopath. Five
treatments and nearly a thousand dollars later he asked me the question that
severed my relationship with him: “How many days a week are you in pain?” On
the surface, a good question, but since I’d filled out a 12-page intake form
detailing location, intensity and frequency of daily pain, I lost all faith in
him. Having broken with Dr. D, I went to an orthopedic surgeon, Dr.
K. Dr. K recommended an MRI right off the bat. The MRI revealed
nothing wrong with the structure of my hips besides the beginnings of arthritis,
but did show ovarian cysts. Dr. K couldn’t get out of the room fast enough. “I
don’t know anything about these internal things, I’m just a bone doctor,” he
said, and recommended Dr. M, a gynecologist. An ultrasound and a blood test
later she offered a hysterectomy. I had high hopes that surgery would solve my
hip pain.
“A hysterectomy for hip pain?” you may ask, incredulous. Only
surgery could confirm whether or not the cysts were cancerous (which they
weren’t), but Dr. K, who’d requested the MRI, two other doctors I haven’t even
mentioned, and lots of hits on the internet suggested that women with back and
hip pain often find relief after a hysterectomy has been done for some other
reason. Dr. M was happy to report in the recovery room that my left ovary had
been fused to my left pelvic wall, “and that,” she said, “could have been the
source of your hip pain.” She never had gotten quite clear that the pain was in
the right hip. But maybe that was the source, I encouraged myself; often back
pain on one side is caused by a problem on the other. For the first three days
after the surgery I was ecstatic. I had no more hip pain! Then I started
cutting back on the codeine and discovered that indeed, my hip still did catch
when I stood, hurt when I walked, ache when I slept.
I was again discouraged, and fear came back into the
equation. My mother died of a rare brain disease which causes multiple system
atrophy, meaning all the muscles shut
down, from the limbs to the esophagus. Most patients die of this disease from
choking on their food or saliva, or from starvation. Others from injuries
sustained in falls. The cause of the disease is unknown, but it has a genetic
component. My mother also suffered from chronic pain in her right “flank,” as
she called it, and I never bothered to dig into exactly what that meant to her.
My right hip began to hurt the autumn I was helping her to die. I could have
the gene that predisposes to this disease. Her flank pain could have been a
symptom of it. My friend Darlene kept attributing her shoulder pain to a fall
she’d taken, at first insisting it was from the impact, and when time ran out
on that reason she decided it was from something being torqued out of place, a
muscle or vertebra… turns out it was a tumor wrapped around her spine. She was
dead three months later. Why should I not worry when I cannot identify the
source of this chronic right hip pain? When I begin to think like this I mix
another martini and try to forget.
Six weeks ago, lifting a giant tortoise to carry him
outside, I felt a twang on my left side. This developed into sciatica. My one
good side was gone. I was truly at the end of my rope. It hurt to sleep, it
hurt to wake up. It’s hard to want to get out of bed and face the day when it
hurts to move. Last week, having hobbled to the health food store to order dog
food, I ran into a woman I hadn’t seen in years.
“You look great,” I said, and she said “I feel terrific. I
discovered this book and I’ve been doing these e-cises forty-five minutes a day
for five weeks. My shoulders don’t slump anymore, my back doesn’t hurt….” She
went on about this program and her radiance persuaded me to look into it. I
ordered the book, Pain Free: a Revolutionary Approach to Stopping Chronic
Pain, by Pete Egoscue. Egoscue believes that almost all chronic pain can be
attributed to musculoskeletal misalignment, and that the human body evolved to move, in bilateral symmetry, not to live
the sedentary life of the 21st Century. In our early years as a
species, when we wanted food we had to spend the day hunting and gathering it,
not get up from the couch, take ten steps to the fridge, pull out a bowl of
mashed potatoes, and flop back down on our butts in front of the TV. He didn’t
say it quite like that.
After all these years of sensing that the source of my pain
lay in asymmetry, trying to decipher and link symptoms, I may have found the key
to correction. After four days of practicing Egoscue’s e-cises, the sciatic
pain has all but disappeared, the tendonitis in my right elbow acquired last
spring during forced labor on the irrigation pipeline is just a twinge, the
ache in my left shoulder from sitting at the computer is minor, and the chronic
pain in my right hip is much improved. Already getting out of bed is no longer
a challenge. If this program of e-cises does solve this hip problem, I will be
even more infuriated at the amount of money spent, time compromised, and
anxiety wasted over the past three years working within bounds of the medical
system. And I have to wonder, if Egoscue’s method works so well, why is this
book, this practice, not a staple for every doctor who deals with muscular and
skeletal pain and dysfunction? Perhaps because then hip and knee replacements
would become rare, arthritis drugs redundant, rotator cuff surgery obsolete?
Insurance companies would go broke if people could treat themselves at home for
free. The medical industry would collapse.
And all those questions the doctors couldn’t answer: What
caused the lack of blood flow to that little piece of ankle bone all those
years ago? Was it sitting curled always to the left in my childhood, pinching
that right groin and restricting blood flow into that right leg? Did I sit
always curled to the left because it was uncomfortable to sit curled to the right,
perhaps because my little growing ovary was even then fusing to my pelvic wall
on the left side? Who knows. Did wearing a cast on that right ankle and
favoring that leg for years cause misalignment of my right knee and hip, lumbar
spine, left shoulder, right elbow? Or is the source of my hip pain not my ovary
or my ankle bone, but that I spent most of 1988 driving around the country in
an automatic car with my left foot braced out the window? One thing is certain.
The ankle bone’s connected to the leg bone, the leg bone’s connected to the hip
bone, the hip bone’s connected to the back bone… I’ve been crooked for nearly
50 years. I think I may finally be straightening out.
***
So it was after Day 4 of e-cises. (Egoscue calls them this
because they are more passive than we generally think of exercise, and because
it’s his system and his name starts with E.) All my aches and pains were
diminished and getting out of bed was easy. But on Day 5 I had some soreness in
my low back. By Day 10 it hurt to move again. What was new about this pain was
that it was evenly distributed. Both sides of my low back hurt equally. A lot,
but equally, “right-side-left-side.” I chalked this pain up to my body
adjusting to its new alignment. I have kept at the program of e-cises –
discipline at last – for at least an hour a day, usually two. Now, on Day 16, I
wake and walk easily, bend to load the woodstove easily, and the aches and
twinges that come on me don’t last long. I have a new appreciation for the
importance of motion in moving
through a day.
I’ve begun to incorporate yoga back into my program, and
find my downward dog is longer, both in stance and duration, and easier. I can
sit lower in Virasana than ever before. In addition to pain-relieving routines
for every joint pair in the body, Egoscue prescribes specific routines for peak
performance in many sports and a daily maintenance routine that incorporate
some of the yoga poses I’ve been doing for years. It seems that the release on
my right side and the apparent realignment derived from his pain-relieving
program have enabled me to deepen my experience of yoga postures. I see now
that my yoga teacher asked me over the years to do some of the very same things
outlined in the Pain Free routines. Somehow I was not able to accept their
benefits in the same way. Egoscue offers a “supine groin stretch” that he
encourages you to hold for as long as an hour if you are in severe pain. I did
this on the second or third day, and I am convinced that this did more than
anything else to restore balance to, to open, my right hip. Not only did the
groin pain diminish dramatically after that first one hour stretch, but at last
I could actually feel my right heel press into the floor.
In standing poses yoga teachers always say “press into your
back heel,” and I could never feel it on my right side. My ankle did not bend
enough, my calf did not stretch, and even when standing straight in Tadasana I
could not feel my right heel pressing
into the ground. I feel my heel connecting now in all these poses. When I walk,
climb stairs, bend to reach for something on the floor, my right leg feels
different, straight, right, as though for years one part of it hadn’t been
working at all and another had been locked in the wrong place. Perhaps it is
this quite literal grounding that makes my spirits soar this morning. There is
nothing like waking up without pain to give a body energy for living.
-
I finally feel like I’m a real Coloradoan. I looked at
myself the other day, just before Thanksgiving when we hadn’t gotten much snow
yet, just cold enough to build a fire in the woodstove: I sat outside with
morning coffee watching the dogs play. Patches of snow remained from a shower
days earlier not melting, just subliming away, the dry cold bright air sucking
the moisture right out of it. The front and back doors were open, the window
cracked to let the music out, and a merry fire in the black, windowed stove
kept the house warm. Fresh fall air mixed between the doors with the sweet warm
air inside, music wafted out to where I sat on the patio, layered in silk
longjohns, socks, slip on boots, a sweater and a down vest. I suddenly felt like
one of those real Coloradoans I met when I first visited Colorado decades ago,
those hearty young athletic party animals I knew who left open the doors of
their tiny mountain houses in Grand Lake or Crested Butte to let the dogs or
the fresh air or the neighbors run in and out freely, all the while with a
happy fire in the woodstove.
It’s cold in here, I’d say, and they’d say, Yeah, but it’s
warmer than outside. They were layered in silk and nylon and wool with down
booties and vests and often a tasseled hat or just a cap on their hip young
heads. Well, I’m not necessarily hip and I’m no longer young in quite that way,
but I’ve finally simply found myself now in that situation that was both alien
and envious when I first encountered it. A lifestyle, perhaps, more than a
situation. Just this morning I was over at Suzi and Geoff’s house for coffee,
breakfast, a puppy play date, and a hot tub. The night before a bunch of us had
driven home in several cars from a concert in town 20 miles away through a blizzard.
The concert was fantastic. I don’t go out much, but when a
group this fabulous comes to town I don’t want to miss them, and the weather
seemed to have cleared by the time I picked up everyone to drive in for dinner.
We ate at Eleni’s Greek Restaurant, an intimate dining room, hot sweet potato
French fries with garlic aioli and an Aegean Platter for appetizers, genial
conversation among seven friends, visits from Eleni, warm out of the kitchen
and jovial despite her sorrows, and perfect timing to depart for the show down
the road. The theater was packed. Feast is a popular chamber music quartet with
an electronic twist. They dazzled us, took us on a world journey and a wild
ride, seduced us with samba, performed Enescu and Freddy Mercury with flawless
technical finesse and unbridled delight. The audience both laughed and sat
rapt, leapt to their feet more than once for a standing ovation. The men on
stage behind the cello and the drums were mild and dignified, the two women in
red sparkled. No one could take their eyes for long off of the former Miss Alaska
in her red sequined slip of a dress as she burned the bowstrings on her
virtuoso violin.
This group has ties to our town and plays there a couple of
times a year. Their reputation is growing around the west, and locally it was a
sold out standing room only show. Tyme and Kathryn Mientka brought a new
level of classical performance and teaching to the town some years ago, and now
they’ve spoiled us for anything less than world-class classical in our venues.
(Or our veins.) David Alderdice, the dreadlocked drummer, makes magic with his percussion
kit. And slender, alabaster Audrey Solomon simply shines with true star presence. Their
music defies description, other than to say it moves people to leap out of
their seats when it’s over and beg for more. It moves people. It makes us laugh
and catch our breath.
Out of the warm packed theater buzzing with goodwill we
streamed into a slanting icy snow that had already coated roads and cars with
sticky slush. I discussed our route home with my passengers: the highway we
decided would carry too much potential for risk from other drivers on the ice.
We took the back road. There we decided the slightly longer route with more
curves was preferable to the route with the short steep hill that led to the
other highway. The amiable banter among my friends was a great steadying
comfort to my nerves as I pursued the road home. Snow came in blinding sheets
truly horizontally most of the way. Visibility was almost desperate at times. I
could feel the Blizzack snow tires losing their grip now and then. I crept home
at 25 or 30 mph, blazing the trail through inches of unbroken snow and slush
for miles. A car behind us kept its distance, then turned off – our friends
Ruth and Jeff, so we knew they were safely home. I delivered two companions to
their house, and the road from there to Crawford was nearly clear – wet and
slushy but visible. I dropped another two off in town at their car, and turned
toward home. By the time I got to the edge of the canyon, two blocks through
town, snow was coming down hard again. Another car was ahead of me going down
the canyon, and for a short way I had their tracks to follow. Then the hail
opened up, with a lightning blast that whitened the entire sky and seemed to
come from nowhere. By the time I got to the curve in the bottom of the canyon
and could see the taillights that I hoped were Geoff and Suzi’s climbing the
other side, I could no longer see their tracks on the sheet of white pellets
covering the road.
The steep hill up the other side would have worried me had I
not known that just five minutes earlier it had been pretty clear. My little
Honda with the kickass snow tires made it easily and I caught up with the other
car in time to flash goodnight as it turn down my friends’ road. Visibility was
about 20 feet the rest of my drive home, just a couple of miles. In my own
driveway I released my seatbelt and heaved a sigh. I hate drives like that. I
make it a point to avoid them. I’d rather stay home than drive in that kind of
extreme for just about anything. But I was calm and happy. My friends in the
car had kept up a light conversation, about the music, about pets, about sunny
California, every now and then thanking me: I’m so glad you’re driving, one of
them said, You’re our hero, said another, and sotte voce one or another
checking in with How are you doing, Reets, you OK? Yes, thank you, I said, and
the surprising thing is that I was. If I’d been making that drive home solo I’d
have been fist-clenching anxious about it, close to panic, not knowing at its
worst if it would get even worse, if I’d have to pull off and wait, imagining
scenarios of sliding off the road, coming upon an ugly accident, all the worst
that could happen in a blizzard miles from home on a dark back road. The Not
Being Alone gave me tremendous calm, and their sincere confidence in me, in my
extreme-weather driving, bolstered my own. We all agreed to check in by phone
when I arrived home.
I let the pack of dogs out into the blizzard and picked up
the phone to let John and Ellie know I was home, then checked on Phillip and
Pamela who’d had farther to go than I. They were in and their dogs were covered
in snow as mine were within seconds of going out. Then I double checked with
Suzi and Geoff though I was pretty sure they’d turned ahead of me. I couldn’t
quite ID the car though, in the snow, just see that it was turning. We were all
home, my whole pack was safe for the night. I know myself. I know that in
previous winters a drive like that would have had me reaching for the bottle
the minute I walked in the door to take the chill off the stress. Last night
after tucking in my friends and wiping off the dogs I poured a glass of water
and lay down on the couch to breathe. I let the memory of that fabulous music
wash over and through me, and wrapped myself in the warmth of my community –
that larger group that swelled with joy at the concert, and the smaller group
of travelers through the blizzard who had all, together in our separate cars,
gotten us all through it safely.
I don’t know yet if everyone who was out that night in our
villages got home okay. If any of our friends slid out on the ice or crashed
into each other or into deer or elk, plunged over ditches or lost their lives.
I held thoughts for all the travelers away from that little paradise of music
and light into the storm. I know that this morning, when Suzi woke me up with
an invitation to watch the sun come up from the hot tub, I couldn’t say no. The
sense of being close, being watched over, being part of, carried me back out
into the snow. I drove through the dazzling clarity of the uncloudy day to the
pleasures of coffee, raspberry pancakes, bacon, recollections of the concert, and
a long leisurely soak noticing snow defining new ridges on familiar mountains.
After breakfast we sat on the porch sipping more coffee, warmth from the tub
and the food and the friendship sustaining our conversation on this cold and
perfect Colorado morning.
-
I am for sure a better pet owner for knowing this vet.
Tonight as my old dog wobbles in from her evening walk I remember when he
diagnosed her a year and a half ago with renal failure. He said “I’ve seen some
dogs go two weeks from this point, and some go two years.” I didn’t like him
the first time I took my cat to see him fifteen years ago. He was brusque with
her and with me. The other day I took in little Vincent with a similar problem
to that old cat, who lived fourteen more years. Dr. Vincent was like a
different vet.
I suspect he may have changed a little, but what’s really
changed is my perception of him. When he whisked that calico cat away from me fifteen
years ago, and said as he was turning his back, “She needs an enema, call me
this afternoon,” I was stunned. No further explanation, no chance to say
goodbye to my kitty, and he was gone. I stood around for a minute then left.
Once I picked up the cat that afternoon I didn’t go back to him for six years.
I found another vet ten minutes farther away. She was an excellent vet, and I
was very happy with her care of all my animals for years.
Then one night the old knobby-headed dog was stricken,
bloated tight and crying under the stairs, and my vet didn’t answer the phone.
I called the next vet down the valley, and rushed the dog there at 10 at night.
He said “Your dog is fine. Whatever it was is over.” That was a relief. But it
was wrong. The ailment recurred a few months later. I tried my usual vet, who
once again wasn’t home. Believing knobby-headed dog would be fine, I walked him
around the yard for hours, but his pain increased. Finally, at 3 in the morning
with much trepidation, I broke down and called Dr. Vincent.
“Bring him in right now,” he said. When I arrived half an
hour later he was waiting for me with The Book open on his table. He showed
pictures of a dog’s stomach twisted over on itself. “Gastric torsion,” he said.
“This is what it was last time. Occasionally taking a dog for a car ride will
create just the right conditions for the stomach to untwist. It usually
requires surgery to fix it, and even that might not work. In 20 years I’ve done
ten of these surgeries. Five dogs have survived. He might make it through the
surgery and die in the next week from the systemic toxins created by the
torsion.”
He took the dog back to the surgery room and gave him a
sedative, then stuck a tube down his throat trying to relieve pressure and get
the stomach to untwist. It didn’t work. By now it was 4 in the morning. He said
“You’ve got three choices. You can take him home and hope it corrects like it
did last time; I can put him down; or I can do the surgery.”
I tried to say “Put him down.” The dog was 11 years old, and
while he had been an excellent companion and protector, he’d also been a trial.
For starters, he always tried to kill any non-human creature that was bigger
than he was. The flaws and strengths of that dog’s character are too numerous
to go into now, but the part of me that wanted an easier life opened my mouth
to say “Put him down.” Instead, out came “Do the surgery.”
“He won’t be the same dog,” cautioned Dr. Vincent.
“That’s fine,” I said with some relief. He gave me two more
chances to change my mind and each time my mind said “Put him down,” but my
mouth said “Do the surgery.” I left and drove to a friend’s house to sleep for
a couple of hours. Knobby-headed dog not only survived the surgery, but a month
later he brought down a fawn in the front yard. He was the same dog. After that
experience, after Dr. Vincent’s gentle and informative explanations of the
problem and possible solutions, after his obvious concern for both the dog and
me, not to mention his total lack of irritation at being waked in the night, I
liked him a lot. Knobby-headed dog lived two more years, and while he became
rapidly more mellow with his advancing years, he remained a pretty scrappy
hound.
Fortunately I did not have too many occasions for a vet for
the next few years. When I did I spread the wealth between the two or three
nearest vets. We’re fortunate where I live that there are half a dozen fine
vets within less than an hour, all of whom help out with strays and broken
wildlife as well as paying customers. I take the old dog to a holistic vet an
hour from home because diet, homeopathy and supplements work better on renal
failure than standard treatments. But ever since Dr. Vincent solved two
diagnostic mysteries on two dogs in less than a minute each, I pretty much converted
completely.
He’s been my primary vet now for 7 years. He has never been
brusque with me again, and he has unfailingly explained in detail what is wrong
and what I need to do to help my pet. In short, he has taught me. He makes
jokes and laughs readily when I tease him. He offers options when they exist,
and confidence when they don’t. With each visit to him I learn something new
about how to treat an abscess, or how a stool softener works and why it doesn’t
mix with oil, or when a cat’s lip might need to be cut off.
The old calico I first took to him died last year. Three
days later I was out in the garden and I heard a strange sound. I thought at
first it was some unusual bird, but as my ears sorted it out I realized with
dismay it was a cat crying quite nearby. I found him under a tree not 20 feet
from the calico’s grave, a tiger tabby with a bloody mouth and bloody paws. I
scooped him up and held him to my chest. It was love at first sight. It’s
impossible to articulate the feeling that passed between that cat and me in
those first moments of holding him. I didn’t even take time to call. I rushed
him to the car and, murmuring reassurance to him all the way, drove him up the
valley to Dr. Vincent’s office. I needed a name to murmur. “Vincent,” I said,
“it’s ok, you’re going to be fine.”
At the clinic Doc came out from emergency surgery during his
lunch hour and said “What have we got?” “He’s bleeding from his mouth,” I said.
“I just found him. If you can fix him I’ll keep him. Please fix him.” He
whisked him into the back saying “Call me in three hours.” That was the sum
total of our exchange. I realized then that his haste with me that first visit
had been solely a result of an emergency situation. For six years my knee-jerk
emotional reaction had kept me from knowing and learning from this
extraordinary doctor and teacher.
I called him in three hours. “It’s calicivirus,” he said, “a respiratory virus that has ulcerated his
tongue. If I can save the tongue I can save the cat. A cat can’t survive
without a tongue. He needs it to drink. I’ve seen it before but I’ve never seen
it this bad.”
“You better save him,” I said. “I named him after you.”
Dr. Vincent laughed. “Well I’ll have to save him then,” he
said. “If he makes it over the weekend I think he’ll be fine.”
Monday morning little Vincent emerged from the back room
looking like a new cat. “He’s a remarkable cat,” said his namesake. “I just
gave him an anti-inflammatory. He did the rest. Really, he’s a special cat. You
can take him home tomorrow,”
“Only I can’t,” I said. “I leave home for a month tomorrow.
Any chance you could keep him for me until I get back?”
“I don’t see why that would be a problem.”
A month later I returned to the clinic to pick up my new
cat. He was the darling of the staff. He came into my arms as though he’d known
me forever. The doctor charged me a pittance for everything. But this is what
he would do for anyone, for any cat. He’s a small-town vet who works all hours
for the valley’s pets. He donates and discounts his services for the local animal
rescue group. He works in a room open to the front desk and the waiting area. I
never mind waiting my turn, watching and eavesdropping in fascination and
admiration as he diagnoses, treats and explains each patient in front of all
the rest.
A few months after acquiring little Vincent I took in one of
the dogs and Doc asked after his namesake. “He’s great,” I said. “He is so
smart. Sometimes he’s so smart I call him Dr.
Vincent.” The real Dr. Vincent almost blushed.
Vinnie goes back to his vet every now and then when he gets
in a fight outside at night. Last week he went in for an abscess on his tail.
This week for a fecal blockage, the same condition that introduced me to Dr.
Vincent fifteen years ago. “This is too far up for an enema to do any good,” he
said. “We’ve got to approach this from the other end.” He gave me a week’s
worth of stool softeners with a pill plunger to get them down. “These pills are
bitter, they’ll make him drool. Don’t be alarmed. Keep an eye on that cat for
me, I mean it.”
Today, rather than phone, I dropped by when I was in the
neighborhood to get a report on blood work for one of the dogs. The parking lot
was jam packed. I stood in the center of a hubbub of ailing kittens, nervous
dogs, and their people, watching and waiting until he had a chance to talk with
me. I watched him take a phone call while he turned off the lights and looked
at a cat’s injury with his eye scope. He took his time with me between patients,
explained the blood work and discussed options, then patiently heard my report
on little Vinnie’s progress. I walked out of the chaos of the clinic calm,
informed, and, as usual, a little bit enlightened. I hope he’s not planning to
retire any time soon. I want this vet to keep tending my pets and my education
for many years to come.
-
The other day I called a childhood friend I’d located on the
internet. I left a message at his work. The first day, after I left the message,
I imagined a lot of scenarios. He’d call me back or he wouldn’t, he’d say this,
I’d say that, this or that would happen down the line… I busied my mind with
possibilities for awhile in my excitement to have found him. Doing so, I began
to wrack my brain to remember how and why we had lost touch with each other.
Then I was overtaken with a sickening feeling as all that emerged from my
memory was a big black hole around the middle of high school. Now the imaginary
scenarios shifted from the future to the past. What had happened?
The first-day scenarios ranged all the way from I’d called
the wrong man to we end up lovers for life. I admit I called him partly because
his resume, which was one of two things I’d located online, stated his marital
status as single. And one reason I’d been thinking of him was that I’d been
examining my life, my own marital status, my current relationships, and some unproductive
behavior patterns. I’m not happy with myself right now, for a lot of reasons. One
is, I’m finally lonely. Or, I’m finally admitting that I’m lonely, that might
be more accurate. But I have serious trust issues (some might say “intimacy
issues”). And in reflecting on the nature and origins of these issues, I fell
to pondering men in my life that I have trusted, with whom I have felt
completely at ease. There aren’t many. Out of the depths of memory swept this
scene of a bike ride, and then a flood of feeling for that boy who was once my
best friend.
Let’s call him Paul. Paul was one of my best friends in
junior high. My first reaction when I found the link to his bio was pure
delight. Only long after I’d left the message did I begin to ponder what had
happened. My second-day scenarios took an uncomfortable twist as I wondered:
Did we slide out of each other’s lives simply from the passage of time? Or, and
here’s where it got really sickening, had I hurt him? Had I done something that
ended our friendship? Had he become interested in me in a way that I did not
reciprocate and I broke his heart? (This speculation tells you a lot more about
the subsequent course of my life than it does about who I was at the time.) Or,
had he hurt me? Had he chosen another girl and broken my heart?
If he should ask me today why I called I’d have to say I’m
making amends. I’ve been rash and heartless with a few friends, I’ve been
thoughtless or careless with many more. I wanted even more to reconnect
because, when I realized there was a big blank at the end of our childhood
friendship I feared I had hurt him – rejected him, judged him, in some way
severed the friendship of my own volition. I’ve done it before and since and
usually regretted my haste. Since my mother’s death from a rare brain disease,
I have been noticing my own memory lapses with a different perspective. There’s
no time to keep making clumsy mistakes with people. If I have hurt people in my
past or present and I can apologize now is the time to start. If I’ve done
damage of any kind and I can make it right, now is the time to start. I don’t
know how much time I have.
I have remembered all along the sense of being with Paul. He
has come to the forefront of my thoughts from time to time, though through many
years he never occurred to me. But when he does occur to me, always, it is with
regret that I do not know what happened to him, that somehow that innocent,
trusting friendship we had as children has disappeared. Vanished into the vast
past, even the memory of our friendship has drowned in the flood of experiences
that came on top of whatever we were in that long-ago slice of time. We rode
bikes sometimes, saw each other outside of school even though we lived a long
way apart and our parents had to shuttle us to play with each other. I remember
one bike ride in particular, coasting down the paved bike path of Four Mile
Run, trees arching over the path, and Paul and me laughing, a lot. I can see
him laughing now, clear as day.
But what prompted me to call? I’ve been thinking lately,
wondering at my aloneness, in this hermitage I’ve set up for myself on this
mesa, in this forest, in this mud hut where I live with lots of animals and
which I rarely leave. Why indeed would a big city professional want or need a
friendship with me? Why would a man who was once a boy I knew bother to call
back to see who I am now? On one level, I am simply curious about how he has
grown up, who he has become. Is that arrogant of me? And on the other end of that spectrum lives the romantic fantasy
of childhood sweethearts hooking up again at their 50th high school
reunion. I’ll never get a reunion with Paul, we went to different high schools.
If I was to ever know anything about him I had to track him down myself.
I keep avoiding the real issue, though. Which is why did I really call him? It was impulse, to be
sure, under some influence beyond my control. Here is the truth of it. I have
known a lot of men since I was friends with Paul. And from this vantage point,
in that span of time, I have never been as comfortable with any of them as I
was when I was a child, riding bikes and laughing with my friend. I remember
his happiness during those short young years we were friends. I have pictures
of him at parties at my house. I do not recall too many specifics, but I
remember feeling safe with him to be myself. People and relationships are
fraught with tensions and threats, but in that happy young friendship I
remember neither.
I have felt safe a few times with some of my lovers, but
that feeling has never lasted. I have subsequently molded myself to the needs
and desires of whatever man I’ve been with, giving up my self to be a couple.
I’ve been verbally abused by my father, my brother and most of my lovers. The
one lover who did not abuse me with his words was the cop who cheated on me. I
do not trust men. I’ve made a string of bad choices. I’ve learned a lot of
lessons, most of them more than once. I know I’ll never make some mistakes
again. I think from time to time of that boy Paul that I knew and I remember a
boy who was kind and funny and smart, with whom I could let my imagination, my
laughter, my intellect, simply be. We were friends when we were children,
untarnished by life’s deceptions, intrigues and betrayals. Before we knew we
had issues. I wonder what kind of man he has become.
What happened? Why is there a big blank? Did I hurt him? Did
he hurt me and I’ve forgotten? Either way, if it was a bad scene it’s a good
sign that I can’t remember: I’m famous for holding grudges, but thirty years
would be a little long even for me. It’s possible I misremember. It’s possible
in the years of high school and beyond, whatever happened that we fell apart or
grew apart, I made up some story about how we’d been such good friends. Maybe I
was never anything to him. I’ve hardly been anything to myself. And now we’re
down to the real nitty gritty. As usual. Who am I? Who am I that he would want
to be my friend, some boy I knew 35 years ago who has had lifetimes to forget
me, to forget that boy, to build his own rich and fascinating story woven full
of women and men, joys and griefs and experiences uniquely his own. Who am I to
such a one?
I’m someone new each day. I don’t have a steady job, so I am
not defined by my career. I don’t have a husband or a lover so I’m not defined
by a partnership. I have no claim to fame. What is the essence of me that I
have to offer? In another scenario, I congratulate Paul on his accomplishments
in the medical field, and I am forced to confess I have not lived up to my own
expectations of my intellect. I may have satisfied my soul, but I certainly did
not live up to potential in anyone’s eyes who knew me as a child. For crying
out loud, I live in a mud hut in the woods with a bunch of dogs and I rarely
leave home. I wallow in introspection, I tell Paul in this scenario, so I guess
that makes me a poet.
But now it’s after nine on the third day, and he has not
called. Perhaps he is out of town and he will call another day. Or, he will not
call. He does not remember me or he does not wish to reconnect with me. I’m
sure he has his reasons. And I’ve lost nothing with the venture. Imagining Paul
has given me all I could ask for from him, a jumping off point to once again
attempt to get to the root of the question that plagues me daily: Who am I?
Now, a week after leaving the message, I sit down at the
computer today to polish off this meditation on speculation, memory and
identity, with more unsaid in it than said, having concluded, once again, the
usual conclusions: the past is gone and the future unknown, and neither is
worth too much attention. I may never know the present of my old friend Paul,
or if he remembers me, or what transpired in our past, and these mysteries I
must let be. Whoever I am in this present moment, let me be present and kind
and unattached to outcome. Nothing ventured, nothing gained. There’s the phone,
let me get that – well!
It is Paul. The
Paul? I ask. The Paul who was my friend when I was a child? And he says: Still
is. My heart fills with joy to hear these two words. I feel wildly happy. His
voice has grown up but the warmth and humor remain. He remembers me well. We
fall to talking and he tells me he lives with a gentleman, has for years. Damn!
It figures. The most comfortable man I can remember in my life and he turns out
to be gay. No wonder I never felt threatened. My enthusiasm shifts, my voice
falters. A fleeting disappointment dissolves in recognition, relief. There is
no sordid past to rectify. There is no other woman to object or be jealous – we
are free to rekindle our friendship. My delight at having found him burgeons.
Of course he is gay. I have known this somewhere all along. There is so much to
say. But he’s at work. He gives me his home number. We exchange promises to
talk more and get together, and these promises feel true and happy to me. I
have found my friend again, and these 35 years have all but disappeared.
Still I am left with questions. Whatever happened, I did not
understand it at the time. There was something, some scene, some uncomfortable
conversation, I feel sure of it. The sickening feeling returns. Did I have
feelings for him that were not reciprocated? Did I press him? Did I judge him? Did
he tell me he was gay and I walked away from the friendship? Or did he not tell
me, did he not know, could he not say, and I just didn’t get it? The end of our
childhood relationship remains a blank. Perhaps these questions can be answered
now that I’ve found him. Perhaps they don’t matter. And, knowing better than to
anticipate outcome, I (whoever I am) imagine welcoming him and his partner to
my home, can see them arriving through the gate, can feel me wrapping them both
in hugs with a heart wide open to a new, grownup friendship.