engaging the spirituality of everyday life   
Welcome to The Virtual Teahouse Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

Bill Ellis

Read Any Good Books Lately?

I have made myself way too busy in the last month, and have neglected more important things.  My need to check in with the VTH finally overcame the intertia of administrative stuff and has led me to write about a book I just finished.  I realize this isn't necessarily the venue for book reviews, but it is a Virtual Tea House, and people talk about what they have read over tea, don't they?

 Anyway, I recently finished Karen Armstrong's latest book "The Case for God."  It is well worth the read.  For those who don't know her, Karen was raised a Roman Catholic in England, and as a little girl she aspired to become a nun, which in due course is exactly what she did.  Didn't work.  Lots of reasons.  She left the convent and organized religion, eventually becoming what she described as an "undifferentiated monotheist."  Along the way she wrote a bunch of books and became one of the non-muslim world's greatest experts on Islam, a religion she views with great understanding and sympathy. 

Her newest book, "The Case for God." makes the plea for a return to the tradition of what is called "apophatic spirituality," that way of understanding God which realizes we understand nothing much at all, which in fact finds that when we have pushed the limits of human language, and metaphor and knowledge and understanding and rationality as far as we can go, what is left is nothing but awe and wonder at the still limitless, infinite reality that stretches before us.  What we know, most simply put, is that we know nothing about God, and that needs to be enough.  It is a spirituality that stresses compassion, rather than comprehension, reconciliation, rather than rote, devotion, rather than dogma, and describes faith not as the ability to agree with certain propositions about the nature of God, but as the ability to trust completely in that which is beyond all understanding.  It is a spirituality that is very old, and in the western world anyway, has deep roots in the Hebrew bible and the first thousand years of so of Christian spirituality. 

It seems to me that this is also the natural spiritual perspective of the VTH.  It isn't that we all agree, because you don't have to read very many posts to realize that we all come to this virtual place with not just with different ideas and experiences, but with different ways of framing those ideas and experiences.   But I do notice that within the context of this great variety most of us have along the way given up on the notion that faith is about believing concepts, and religion is about ritual enactments.  We all have concepts and rituals, and we use them to great effect, but we don't believe in them in any more; we don't believe they do any more than to point us in the direction of that ineffable presence that is everywhere, and yet beyond everywhere, that is in everything, and yet is no-thing.  In reading her book I found myself rediscovering my own experience through another person's eyes, which I experienced not so much as a vindication of my own opinions, as an affirmation of the mystery of life itself. 

Now Armstrong is what my good friend Ray Jeff Sprier would call a "propeller head."  Her language is not technical - she is really good about writing for non-professional audiences - but it is academic; the footnotes take up a big hunk of the volume.  Those seeking an exploration of the deeply affective side of life are not going to find it here.  But those who feel lonely in their spirituality in this modern world of certainty about God, who want some company out on the edges where knowledge fails, and rationality collapses into paradox, will find this book richly rewarding, provided you can embrace the style in which she approaches the subject.  I could embrace that style, and I am grateful for her company in my own long strange trip.      

  

Published Monday, January 25, 2010 12:05 PM by Bill Ellis

Comment Notification

If you would like to receive an email when updates are made to this post, please register here

Subscribe to this post's comments using RSS

Comments

 

tania said:

You hit on two of my favorite things to discuss over tea:  a good book and spirituality.  What I found myself most interested in was the story of her -- of how she came to discover all she knows for herself and of her trials and tribulations at leaving "the" church.  Do you know of a book she's written in which she points to her own life?  She sounds like a fascinating person -- a bodhisattva of sorts.  Thanks for turning me onto her!

January 30, 2010 12:06 AM
 

Beth Patterson said:

Hi Tania--I'm sure Bill will answer you, but wanted to let you know that Karen has written a remarkable book about her journey and its struggles and gifts called

The Spiral Staircase: My climb out of darkness

http://www.amazon.com/Spiral-Staircase-Climb-Out-Darkness/dp/0385721277/virtuteaho-20

I've listened to it on CD, with her reading it. It's a great memoir of an important thinker in our times.

January 30, 2010 11:14 AM
 

Beth Patterson said:

Bill--

I'm going to read 'The Case for God'.  It seems like it would be very insightful to where I am on my journey.

Thanks for this book review.  Always appropriate here at the VTH!!

January 30, 2010 11:16 AM
 

Bill Ellis said:

Tania,

Beth has given you the title of the best autobiographical volume Karen has written.  "The Spiral Staircase" is shorter than her other books, and it will give you good insight into her journey.  The other thing to do is to go listen to her some time.  She is brilliant and hilarious, a real delight.  Watch for her.  

January 30, 2010 1:57 PM
 

Ken Sandine said:

Bill, you hint at what faith is “not.”  Ray Jeff Spreier recently hosted a webcast by the Trinity Institute entitled “Building and Ethical Economy:  Theology and the Marketplace.”  One of the things I got out of it is this is that in a parallel way, capitalism, in the context of a market system that provides for the exchange of goods and services, has a faith notion when an ingredient is “trust.”  A transaction, agreed to with a handshake, elevates a relationship to one of trust, which seems to me to embrace the fragrance of faith without a belief “in” anything.  Would this fit with your thinking?      

January 31, 2010 10:30 AM
 

Bill Ellis said:

At first blush I like that metaphor even though I don't know quite how far to push it.  Trust is something you cannot see at all, though we can discern that it is real because it changes people's behavior and attitudes.  It is pointed at, though not controlled, by the ritual you describe, a handshake.  So that parts works.  On the other hand I am inclined to think that trust is a human construct, whereas God is beyond all human constructs, so again I like it as a metaphor but don't necessarily want to push it too far.

Capitalism has long identified "the market" with its "invisible hand" regulating the relationship between supply and demand in harmonious cooperation as its resident diety.  It is of course an easily manipulated idol, as many huge corporations, struggling daily to discover ever new ways to destroy competiton, have demonstrated.  

January 31, 2010 12:31 PM
 

Ken Sandine said:

How far do we push a metaphor?  A theme of “Building an Ethical Economy” suggests that we can “leverage” our language and give it more “currency.”  Alternative words can introduce more color (visual) and flavor (taste) into the lexicon, with the potential of clarifying what we are as humans.  So, accepting the “risk” of oversimplification and pushing the metaphor too far, a gesture of trust (a handshake confirming a transaction) can clarify the sensation of trust.  That gives us closer proximity to what I call the “why” of Jesus.  As you said, we can never hope to comprehend God, who “is beyond human constructs,” but can’t we “profit” more from the “abundant wealth” that can be liberated by hearing “the music” you described in a prior blog.  What did Jesus know about “leverage” and the assumption of “risk” in the choices he made?  What kind of “risk assessment” should go into a good metaphor?

February 4, 2010 11:24 AM
 

Bill Ellis said:

Ken,

I think you are right on all those counts.  we can indeed "profit" from the more "abundant wealth" that is liberated by hearing the "music" of life itself.  And though I am no literalist, there are some passages in which Jesus makes definite risk assessments, such as "those who would follow me must deny themselves, take up their cross, and follow. For those who would save their lives will lose them, and those who lose their lives will save them."  I don't think he said that, the church did, since by then there was some experience of crucifixion at a very practical level.  But it illustrates your point.  We have only to understand that the "economy" of the kingdom operates with a different kind of currency.      

February 4, 2010 7:27 PM

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(optional)
(required) 
Submit

About Bill Ellis

I am an Episcopal priest. Since September of 2006 I have been the Dean of the Cathedral of St. John the Evangelist in Spokane, Washington. I am however a lifelong Oregonian, and consider Oregon to be my childhood religion. Bend was my home for fourteen years before coming to Spokane, but I have lived in Forest Grove, Eugene, (my spiritual Mecca) Coos Bay and Newport, as well as Ashland. I have been married since 1978 and we have two girls, both grown and gone to the wide world.
Developed by Black Crater Software Solutions Powered by Community Server (Personal Edition), by Telligent Systems Logo by Broadway Studios

Copyright © 2007 Virtual Teahouse and Black Crater Software Solutions LLC