engaging the spirituality of everyday life   
Welcome to The Virtual Teahouse Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

Bill Ellis

What Was the Question Again?

In a recent exchange of comments about another blog Beth wondered if perhaps I might compose something on the work of Douglas Adams, author of "The Complete Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy," an English radio program that became a series of books, unless it was the other way around.  "The Guide" is more than a bit like Dr. Who on acid, which I suspect is exactly the effect Adams desired, and therefore any attempt to make sense of these books is a clear violation of their spirit, and not to be countenanced.  So, in keeping with the spirit of these books I shall violate their spirit and attempt to make sense of them, at least in one small regard. 

 One of the many convoluted subplots revolves around finding the answer to "life, the universe and everything."  A super giant computer assigned the task began to crunch all the possibilities, and after several million years concluded its work with a definitive statement.  The answer to "life, the universe and everything" turned out to be "42," a conclusion that felt, well somehow inadequate to the protagonist, an alien who took the name "Ford Prefect."  The problem quickly surfaced.  We now have the answer, but we do not yet have the question, and the answer is meaningless without the question.  The mice, who were really running the show, suggested "How many roads must a man walk down?" as a provisional try, and that was deemed an acceptable substitute until the real question could be uncovered after several million more years using another computer (which turned out to be the planet Earth.)

Granted, the whole thing is wonderfully ridiculous, which is the point.  But I couldn't help thinking, as I laughed my way through this entire story, that Adams was on to something that is actually rather important.  Trying to find some sort of "ultimate meaning" in the existence of a tiny carbon based life form that somehow became sentient only in the past few million years, living on a small planet situated within a spiral arm of a galaxy that is100,000 light years across, itself located at some indeterminable point in a universe that is 13 billion years old (give or take a billion years) seems to me to be, well, about as absurd as Douglas Adams made it all seem. Long before beginning to read Adams I had given up that quest.  But I am very intrigued by the notion of asking "What is the question to which life, the universe, and everything, is the answer?" I like that question, and it doesn't take an earth-sized computer to begin to play with it.  Having tried a number of possibilities the question I have lit upon is this: What does God's love look like?  I like this question because it evokes several different affective responses, depending upon which level of the question is being answered.  At the level of the universe and the earth it feels really good.  Yes, this whole giant thing, this finite but unbounded, incomprehensibly huge physical mystery in which we find ourselves is and must be exactly what God's love looks like, from the greatest black holes, to the nebulae that are themselves larger than our solar system, to the tiny flowers that bloom on high mountain meadows but one week a year, unseen by all but a few creatures - this whole great giant in its collective immensity is what God's love looks like.  When I think about humanity, though, the answer becomes problematic: is this whole human enterprise with its own kind of love and hate, its creative and destructive tendencies, are we all part of what God's love looks like?  Then of course it becomes truly painful when I get down to the subatomic level and ask "am I what God's love looks like? 

But the answer to all of it is "yes;" all of it, including us, including you and me, is what God's love looks like.  What does God's love look like? That is my question to which "life, the universe and everything" is the answer.  So now, for those who want to play as well, why don't you work on this one.  Turn on your giant earth-sized computer before the Vogons blow it up to make room for a galactic superhighway and begin to crunch the question.  Then, if you like, post in the comments section and we can all compare notes.  In the mean time, remember the words inscribed in friendly letters on the front of every copy of the Hitchhiker's Guide: "Don't Panic."   

 

Published Friday, January 30, 2009 2:04 PM by Bill Ellis

Comment Notification

If you would like to receive an email when updates are made to this post, please register here

Subscribe to this post's comments using RSS

Comments

 

Beth Patterson said:

Hi Bill--great post!

You've pre-empted us...but in the interest of not being  prey to the panic of not having an acceptable question, here's mine.

A question to the answer of 'life, the universe and everything' is that there is no answer that fits that whole magilla.  As a Gnostic-type Christian panentheist...have I left anything out...If I really thought I had a big enough question, I'm afraid my personal theology would dunk me in the Hypocrisy Tank.

However, on a living level, your question is so profound, especially as you say, 'am I what God's love looks like?'  I know, but often ignore, that our lives are many people's only sacred text.  But, stlil I know it.  And when I wake to that awareness, it's as if I stand straighter, feel my heart open, and look around with new eyes to the thought of being a living breathing text of the answer.  

But, all that aside, I still think '42' is the best answer yet.  It's a lot less convoluted, although maybe it appears that way because I don't yet understand 42.

Love the challenge, Bill--maybe we should ask all the bloggers on the Tea House to blog to it?

January 31, 2009 12:01 PM
 

Geraldine said:

Speaking of great stories, how's your book project coming along Beth? The first Write A Book Challenge update is posted over at MPP. Hope to see you soon. And yes, incubation is good!!!  ;<)

Hugs, G

January 31, 2009 2:23 PM
 

Liz C. said:

The challenge woke me up this morning.  What is the question that the answer is "life, the universe and everything?"  Bill's option assumed a higher being called "God" and the expression of an emotion.  It, at first, was very comforting.  Both assumptions answer a lot of questions.  My next thought was to get critical.  Maybe life etc. is the expression of the laws of being.  (What are the laws of being?") I smiled at myself- so typical of me to say rules or laws because I am most comfortable when I know what is expected of me in any given situation.  My next question (to answer the question) was "What does the expression of free will look like?"  Now that I disgarded immediately- there may be a will in creation, but in no way is it free, especially human will.  I know this from watching "The Matrix" :) but also from twin studies. We are too affected by genetics, culture, disease, and experience to say what we do is a free expression of our will.

I realized at some point that whatever answer we give is a bit of a Rorschach test as to how we view God. We will still be making God or the universe into our image.

Not to belabor my point any further, the question I settled on in which the answer is life, the universe and everything is " What am I unable to understand- what is mystery?"  I am content with that though eager to read what others say because though I accept mystery as a given I like collecting pieces of the puzzle.

February 1, 2009 4:21 PM

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(optional)
(required) 
Submit

About Bill Ellis

I am an Episcopal priest. Since September of 2006 I have been the Dean of the Cathedral of St. John the Evangelist in Spokane, Washington. I am however a lifelong Oregonian, and consider Oregon to be my childhood religion. Bend was my home for fourteen years before coming to Spokane, but I have lived in Forest Grove, Eugene, (my spiritual Mecca) Coos Bay and Newport, as well as Ashland. I have been married since 1978 and we have two girls, both grown and gone to the wide world.
Developed by Black Crater Software Solutions Powered by Community Server (Personal Edition), by Telligent Systems Logo by Broadway Studios

Copyright © 2007 Virtual Teahouse and Black Crater Software Solutions LLC